Can I just vent here a minute?
I live in Chicago. It’s cold and sloppy outside. I don’t drive. I walk and take public transportation everywhere I go. Thus, I need boots to live. Tall boots. Warm boots. Flat or very low heeled boots. Boots that are stylish enough for the professional workplace. Boots that will zip over my calves.
Oh. Right. That last one. There’s the rub.
I know, I know. Duo Boots. But listen: THEY ARE OVER $200 USD. For the reasonably priced ones! Plus exorbitant shipping from the UK that takes a month! I understand the reasoning about paying for quality, and about how, by ponying up a car payment you’re making an investment. I hear that. And that makes sense, but only if you’ve got OVER $200 USD lying around. I don’t, but it would not be such a hardship for me to save it up, which makes me unusually fortunate.
Here’s the thing, though. I’d really like to try on the pair of $263 boots (with shipping, etc.) that I want more than anything else in the whole world before I pay for them, wait a month to get them, and then possibly have to pay exorbitant shipping to send them back over the pond when SURPRISE, once again I find that the way that math and measures work in my little world is totally different from the way it works everywhere else. I don’t think that is like some kooky pipe dream.
As I sit here, I’m wearing one Rockport Plainfield boot in black on my right foot, zipped up about halfway, that I ordered from Zappos. I decided to order them because I contacted customer service and customer service told me that the calf circumference was 17 3/4 inches. Perfect, I thought, as I have 18 inch calves and that 1/4 inch deficit would account for the elastic goring and stretch in the leather. Except no. They are actually only 17 inches around, and then only at the very top of the boot. About halfway up, where my freakishly large calves* start to really come into their own, the boots are a mere, Mischa Barton-esque** 14 1/2 inches.
Part of me wants to say, “Oh big deal, they are too tight across the toes, too, and really that heel is verging on too high and you know it, so this is for the best because if you’d been able to zip them up, you would have kept them and then they’d make your feet hurt and you’d have to explain to the husband why you kept them and he’s heard the ‘it’s so hard to find boots to fit my freakishly large calves that I tend to be grateful for whatever I can get’ story a bajillion times but he still doesn’t quite get it, not having freakishly large calves of his own to try and boot up,” and that’s true all but dammit, DAMMIT, there is little that destroys my resolve to just like my stupid body the way it is and never diet again like the way one simple fucking transaction for a life necessity turns into this huge massive undertaking involving research and measuring and calls to customer service and packing tape and standing in line at the post office over and over and over again and then is still ultimately unsuccessful. And I’m not even that fat, ya’ll. I’m either at the high end of “in-betweenie” status or the low end of… whatever comes after in-betweenie status. Medium-fat? Despite my boot drama, I can still nip into Anne Taylor for a new shirt if I dump coffee (actually, it was yogurt but whatever) all over the shirt I’m wearing.
I think that’s what I’m getting at here (well that and just whining because I’m really disappointed). I’m crying tears of fury at my failed attempt to purchase what is a Chicago wardrobe necessity, and I’ve actually got it good. It isn’t a totally kooky request to want to try on clothes or boots before you buy them, to avoid the hassle of carting packages home from work on the train because jerks steal the packages that you have sent right to your house. But if you’re above say, an 18 and you don’t live in a major metropolitan area or if you need an item of specialty clothing or you don’t feel like waiting a week to get your clothes or, God forbid, you just don’t care for all this empire waisted, bedazzled, caftan sleeved nonsense hanging on all the racks of mainstream plus-size retailers,*** that’s your fate. The mail order ghetto.
It’s just stupid.
*No, seriously. My father has freakishly large calves, and even when I was a wee little mini thing I had a hell of a time finding boots to fit. They are bigger now, in accordance with my overall increased size, but still proportionally, they’re some wide calves. I would like to be body positive about this but it’s raining and cold out and my new boots don’t fit and this means I have to stand in line for ten hours at the post office on Monday morning to return them and if somebody was going door to door offering back alley calf-ectomies right now, I would have a hard time turning that down. Even harder if they came with a free pair of these lovelies.
**Sorry, couldn’t resist.
***Although the last time I was this size, around the turn of the century (that is weird to say), the prevailing plus size look was “fundamentalist Christian kindergarten teacher” so I suppose I ought to be grateful for the strides we’ve made.

10 comments
Comments feed for this article
November 21, 2007 at 8:08 pm
jaed
I feel your pain. My calves are even bigger than yours, and I wear a size 12. And I have wide feet. (I once mail-ordered ELEVEN pairs of shoes for a special occasion because I wanted to be sure I’d get at least one that didn’t have to go back, and each and every one was either ugly or actively painful or both.)
Have you tried shoetrader.com? They ship free, and return shipping is also free for those shoes you want to punt, so at least you don’t have to pay for the privilege of being consigned to mail order.
This one might do: Gateway Tall Shaft Boot.
And the heels on this all-stretch one are faintly ridiculous yet compelling.
November 21, 2007 at 8:38 pm
kateharding
Okay, breathe. (Though I totally hear you.)
The bad news is, yes, you’re consigned to the mail order ghetto. The good news is, you aren’t consigned to Duo boots.
I just got these from Eddie Bauer, and after a weekend of wearing, they’re almost TOO baggy on my 17-inch calves. They have a handful of wide-calf styles, which might be worth checking out. (I don’t know what size shoe you wear, but if you happen to be an 8, you’re welcome to try mine on.) Leather really does give, and you can have a cobbler stretch the boots for you, which might be enough (I’ve done it with normal-calf boots before) — and if it’s not, they can add goring for you.
Widewidths dot com also has a few different width options. And if all else fails, you could do something like these, with the full stretch panel. They have more of a heel than you seem to want, but I know David Tate makes some lower ones like that, as well as several wider calf options.
Good luck!
November 21, 2007 at 10:45 pm
OTM
Okay breathing. BREATHING! Also, drinking beer number two. Thank you both for kind words, commiseration, and boot suggestions. Tomorrow is a new day, etc.
Jaed, the eleven shoe order story is so sad! Although those second boots are called “Muffin” and that made me laugh. I would kill myself trying to walk in those, but I would die laughin’.
Kate, I wear a ten or an eleven, depending on how pointy the shoe is. I like the Eddie Bauer riding boots here (I’ve sort of become an Eddie Bauer fangirl ever since you suggested their Blakely fit pants) but that toe looks kind of wicked. Do you go to a particular cobbler? I had a guy in NC put goring into a pair of stompy black Fleuvog boots that a friend gave me many years ago. He didn’t do a very good job, but it was good enough for a pair of boots that were already beat to shit. They are no good for work, though, and I’m kind of afraid to try them on again, in case they are too small.
Thanks again. I am particularly whiny tonight!
November 22, 2007 at 9:12 am
vulture
Otter, maybe you’ve done this already so sorry if I’m being redundant, but one of the things you can do on the Zappos website is to search specifically for wide-calf boots.
Click on here:
http://www.zappos.com/n/es/d/722679595/page/1.html
for dress boots and here:
http://www.zappos.com/n/es/d/722679594/page/1.html
for casual boots.
Even if you what you want is definitely casual, or definitely dressy, it’s worth it to look under both categories, since there is some overlap. I would consider some of the “dressy” boots to be okay for casual wear, and vice versa.
I have the opposite problem as you (narrow calves) and I’ve had good luck with boots I’ve found at Zappos by doing a search for “narrow calf” boots. And at least it’s easy to return stuff that doesn’t work for you.
As a Chicagoan, I totally sympathesize with your plight — winters are miserable enough already without having to endure them without a decent pair of boots.
November 22, 2007 at 12:05 pm
Becky
Have you tried mid-calf boots? I’m also “medium-fat” (hee) with big calves, and I’ve found a couple pairs of mid-calf boots where the top hits just below where my calves start getting big, so they fit pretty well, and still offer decent protection from snow and slush.
November 22, 2007 at 12:18 pm
kateharding
OTM, unfortunately, the cobbler I went to was in Toronto, and I don’t have one here. But it’s a big city — there’s gotta be a good one somewhere. Maybe Colleen would know?
November 22, 2007 at 7:50 pm
Lisa
Your boot woe is my boot woe. I have 15.5″ calves, even, and THERE ARE NO BOOTS ANYWHERE THAT FIT. Fuck them all. I hate them.
November 26, 2007 at 3:16 pm
Tari
Boots. Ugh. I am so there. Between the giant size 12 foot and the giant 19 inch calf, it is hell. (And if I bought $200 boots, my head would splode.)
The best luck I’ve had with boots was through Silhouettes. I don’t see the model I have on their website, but they have some reasonable heel options, decent size variety, and they’re not ugly. Mine have made it through several Chicago winters now, so they’re decent quality, too.
December 12, 2007 at 3:42 am
Natalie
Hi, this is Natalie from Duo.
We came across your blog and understood immediately! We were wondering if you’d like to talk to one of our representatives here about fit?
We are pretty confident that if we take the right measurements from you, we will be able to get you some boots that will fit you perfectly.
If you’d like to email us your phone number or email address, we can get in touch with you to talk boots and fit. If not, good luck and all the best.
Our email address is enquiries@duoboots.com and our phone number is +44 (0)845 070 5588
Thanks,
Natalie
December 12, 2007 at 6:51 am
OTM
Whoa. Thanks! I would love to talk to the fine folks at Duo, but I’ll have to wait until after Christmas. I’ll be in touch! Thank you!